Municipal Socialism’s “YIMBY” Problem
The Housing Crisis and Zohran—which way forward?
Not a single one of the 9,902 apartments built in 21 MIH projects in neighborhoods with average incomes under 40% of AMI would be affordable to the typical local resident–let alone anyone making less than the neighborhood average…In only 23 percent of projects were a majority of ‘affordable’ units affordable to average local residents. In total, 89 percent of apartments approved through project-specific MIH rezonings would be unaffordable to the average neighborhood.
Area Median Income (AMI) is the metric used to determine affordability and income eligibility in New York City. AMI is set by a federal body and affordability is subsequently pegged to it. A household that makes half of the AMI is eligible for affordable housing that is priced at the 50 percent rate. As ANHD demonstrated in a 2022 report, AMI is “a convoluted and increasingly disconnected metric that contributes to equally disconnected—and inequitable—housing policies.”17 For example, in 2022, AMI for a 3 bedroom apartment in the city was roughly $120,000. But that same year, the actual median income of these households was just under $94,000—a full $26,000 or 28 percent difference. This means that substantially more units are allotted the label of “affordable” despite being genuinely unaffordable for most, particularly those in the lowest income brackets. Unsurprisingly, nearly 8 out of 10 rent burdened households make less than 50 percent AMI. The less you make, the more you struggle to pay the rent because there are not actually affordable apartments, despite the proliferation of “affordability.” In New York City, the following are considered low income: $90,720 for a 1 person household, $116,640 for a 3 person household, and $157,500 for a 5 person household. Based on NYC AMI, then, all of the following count as housing for low income tenants: $2,268 for a studio, $2,430, for a 1 bedroom, $2,916 for a 2 bedroom, and $3,370 for a 3 bedroom.18 Anyone who lives in New York understands how absurd this standard of affordability is
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
Comments
Post a Comment